Pizza night can be an easy way to sample the character of Southwest Florida, whether you want a wood-fired pie, a New York-style slice or a family recipe served close to home. These four independently operated stops give Naples and Marco Island diners a useful starting point.
Illustrative image created for The Fahey Team; it does not depict a featured restaurant.
Naples Pizza Stops
LowBrow Pizza & Beer: Wood-Fired Pies in East Naples
LowBrow Pizza & Beer describes its kitchen as focused on wood-fired pizza, scratch-made food and house-made sauces. The restaurant is at 3148 Tamiami Trail East in Naples, making it a convenient option to consider when your day takes you along the East Trail.
Review the current menu, hours and ordering details on the official LowBrow Pizza & Beer website.
Baci Trattoria & Pizza: New York-Style Flavor on Bayshore Drive
Baci Trattoria & Pizza is located at 2740 Bayshore Drive. Its official site highlights New York-style Italian cooking, including hand-tossed pizzas, Grandma pizza, Sicilian pizza and classic Margherita. The Bayshore Drive location also makes Baci a possible meal stop before or after exploring East Naples.
See the current menu and service options on the official Baci Trattoria & Pizza website.
Marco Island Pizza Stops
Joey's Pizza & Pasta House: Family Recipes Since 1997
Joey's Pizza & Pasta House says it has been family-owned and operated since 1997. At 257 North Collier Boulevard, the menu includes hand-tossed thin-crust pizza and specialty choices such as white, five-cheese, vegetable and original Italian-style pies.
Browse current offerings and restaurant details on the official Joey's Pizza menu.
Sami's: Stone-Baked Pizza and a Broad Island Menu
Sami's is at 227 North Collier Boulevard and serves stone-baked pizza alongside pasta, seafood and other lunch and dinner choices. Its current pizza menu includes familiar options such as Margherita and Supreme, plus calzones and stromboli. This broader menu can be helpful when a group wants more than pizza.
Confirm hours, menus and live-music details on the official Sami's website.
How to Plan a Southwest Florida Pizza Night
- Check the restaurant's official website before leaving; hours, menus, seating and ordering options can change.
- Order ahead when takeout timing matters, especially during peak visitor season.
- Compare locations with the rest of your plans. A Bayshore Drive stop feels different from an evening centered on North Collier Boulevard.
- Ask the restaurant directly about dietary needs and kitchen procedures.
Dining Convenience and Your Home Search
Restaurants are only one part of a neighborhood decision, but everyday convenience matters. As you compare properties, consider the routes to dining, beaches, shopping, work and other places you use regularly. Explore Naples homes for sale and local communities or browse Marco Island real estate to see how location fits the lifestyle you want.
For a different local dining idea, read our Naples and Marco Island brunch guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find wood-fired pizza in Naples?
LowBrow Pizza & Beer identifies wood-fired pies as a core part of its menu. Check its official site for current offerings and hours.
Which Marco Island pizza restaurants are featured here?
This guide features Joey's Pizza & Pasta House and Sami's, both on North Collier Boulevard. Their menus and service details differ, so compare the official links before choosing.
Should I verify restaurant details before visiting?
Yes. Restaurant hours, menus, entertainment and service options can change. Confirm current information directly with the restaurant.
Explore Naples and Marco Island with The Fahey Team
Ready to connect your favorite Southwest Florida lifestyle with the right home? Contact The Fahey Team or call 239-595-9093.
Restaurant information checked October 22, 2026 using the official restaurant websites linked above.